Cleaner's Big Win After Being Fired for Refusing Acknowledgment of Country

A Street Sweeper's Fight for Fairness and His New Political Ambitions

A Melbourne man, Shaun Turner, 60, has made headlines after winning an unfair dismissal claim against the Darebin City Council. The case revolves around his objection to the Acknowledgment of Country at a toolbox meeting, which ultimately led to his termination in June 2024. However, the Fair Work Commission ruled in his favor, stating that his dismissal was "harsh" and "disproportionate."

Background of the Dispute

Turner, who works as a street sweeper, raised concerns during a meeting about the necessity of the Acknowledgment of Country at small gatherings. He argued that such gestures should be reserved for more formal or international occasions. His comments were interpreted by some as disrespectful, leading to an investigation into his conduct.

During the meeting, Turner expressed his belief that those who served in the military should be acknowledged rather than Indigenous Australians. He stated, “If you need to be thanking anyone, it's the people who have worn the uniform and fought for our country to keep us free.” This sentiment sparked controversy and eventually led to his dismissal.

Legal Proceedings and Findings

The Fair Work Commission found that Turner’s statements were not delivered in the manner or tone alleged by the council. Deputy President Richard Clancy emphasized that while Turner expressed a different opinion on the Acknowledgment of Country, this did not constitute valid grounds for dismissal.

Clancy noted that Turner’s comments were a spontaneous expression of his views and not intended to be disrespectful. He also pointed out that there was no evidence to suggest that Indigenous employees felt offended by Turner’s remarks. In fact, both Ms. Fuller and Elizabeth Skinner, who were present at the meeting, contacted an Indigenous support person afterward to offer an apology.

Compensation and Future Plans

Following the ruling, Turner received a compensation payout from the council, which he described as "satisfying." He has since decided not to return to work with the council and is now considering running for a spot in the Senate at the next election.

Turner emphasized that his actions were not racially motivated. He shared his upbringing in Broadmeadows, where he played football and interacted with people of all races. He explained that his frustration stemmed from various workplace issues, not from any animosity toward Indigenous Australians.

Public Reaction and Broader Implications

Turner’s case has sparked discussions about the appropriateness of the Acknowledgment of Country in different settings. While some argue that it is a vital gesture of respect, others believe it should be reserved for more significant events. Turner’s experience highlights the complexities surrounding cultural practices and individual beliefs.

His legal victory resonates with many Australians who feel that their opinions are often dismissed or labeled as racist without proper consideration. Turner hopes that his case will encourage more open dialogue about these issues.

Moving Forward

As the Fair Work Commission prepares to hold a hearing regarding his request for reinstatement and the determination of the remedy for his unfair dismissal, Turner remains focused on his future. He is currently evaluating his options and considering how he can contribute to the political landscape in Australia.

Turner’s journey serves as a reminder of the importance of understanding and respecting diverse perspectives, even when they challenge established norms. His story continues to inspire conversations about fairness, respect, and the power of individual voices in shaping societal values.