Trump-Hitler Comparisons May Backfire on Democrats

"I clearly recognize the error in comparing Adolf Hitler’s Third Reich to any other political group," ex-Democratic presidential candidate Al Gore admitted on Monday while addressing a gathering at San Francisco’s Climate Week.

"It was exceptionally wicked, period. I understand," he remarked additional.

Then came the “but.”

But significant lessons can be drawn from the history of that rising menace," Gore stated, citing statements made by the Nazis who asserted that the initial step in gaining power in Germany involved transforming "all issues of truth into matters of power.

"The Trump administration is determined to forge their own favored interpretation of reality," Gore stated, as he delivered his concluding remark.

Gore's employment of a Nazi analogy as a means of attack has grown into an increasingly common occurrence in political discourse.

Each side has employed accusations of Nazism against one another; however, this rhetoric seems to be surfacing more frequently among Democrats lately. They have criticized the Trump administration and what they perceive as the emergence of an autocratic regime in the U.S.

Republicans believe that Democrats are committing a political blunder by drawing parallels that could alienate swing voters and ultimately backfire on their own party.

“A national Republican strategist remarked that both the Democrats and media have exhausted these expressions to such an extent that they've lost all significance," he stated. "One might assume that following two unsuccessful assassination attempts, they would cease employing these absurdly charged terms regarding President Trump and his followers; however, quite the contrary has occurred—they’ve intensified their usage."

Gore is not the sole individual on the left drawing parallels like this. Larry David, the creator of "Seinfeld," depicted attending a meal with Hitler in a recent New York Times opinion piece titled “My Dinner with Adolf.”

David aimed at more than just Trump; he also targeted the comedian Bill Maher, who recently mentioned dining with Trump. Maher commented that the person he encountered wasn’t similar to the version of Trump he frequently ridicules on his HBO talk show.

“I found myself ready to encounter Hitler, the one I had seen and heard in public appearances,” David noted. “Yet, this private version of him was entirely distinct. Surprisingly, he appeared more genuine somehow, as though this were the true face of Hitler. It left me quite bewildered.”

After David’s op-ed published, Maher responded by calling the piece “kind of insulting to six million dead Jews.”

"I believe as soon as you bring up the Hitler comparison, you've already lost the debate," Maher stated.

In the autumn last year, both the media and numerous Democrats were outraged when technology tycoon Elon Musk performed what appeared to be a Nazi-style salute in front of a gathering at a Trump rally held at Madison Square Garden. The event drew further condemnation due to remarks made by a comedian who likened Puerto Rico to an archipelago of drifting refuse.

However, certain individuals on the right viewed this outrage as a critical juncture in the contest between Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris, which aided the GOP candidate in securing another term in the White House.

It appeared to me that both the Democrats and the press were eager to bring up this issue once more," the Republican strategist commented about the Nazi remarks back then. "It only needed a minor incident, such as an uncomfortable gesture, for them to be quick to jump on it.

Among the newer analogies to Nazis, certain Republican members argue that these comparisons have become excessive. They believe that such assertions hinder Democrats from effectively presenting their vision for governing the nation.

“A second GOP political strategist stated, ‘At this stage, it has been overly done to the extent that I doubt it carries significant weight anymore.’ He also mentioned, ‘This approach seems quite superficial as it merely fuels rage rather than addressing the core issue behind any grievances.’” --- A Republican strategic advisor commented, "Nowadays, it feels like we've reached such an excess with this strategy that its impact doesn’t seem substantial. Instead of truly tackling what people object to, all it does is try to ignite more fury."

Several Democrats have voiced concerns regarding the use of Nazi analogies and believe that the party should link these allegations to important issues that resonate with voters.

“A key difficulty lies in conveying not only that you believe this individual resembles something or someone negative such as Hitler or Nazis, but also explaining the reasons behind your comparison, why it poses an issue, and how it affects them personally,” explained a prominent Democratic consultant to The Hill. “Simply stating that Elon Musk performs a Nazi salute isn’t enough; rather, emphasize that he uses such gestures as part of a strategy aimed at making people’s lives more difficult. This approach resonates better than mere name-calling.”

Other people at the gathering contend that he does fit the description and maintain that Trump poses a distinct danger to democratic principles and exhibits signs of fascism.

Many Democrats often bring up the notorious "Unite the Right" rally held in 2017 in Charlottesville, Virginia. After this event, where a violent confrontation occurred between white supremacists and protesters supporting diversity, Trump caused widespread anger when he stated that there were "very good individuals on both sides."

“We have an obligation and an opportunity to call balls and strikes as we seem them, and this ball is coming straight down the plate,” said Antjuan Seawright, a leading Democratic strategist and political operative.

Effective communication often involves sharing difficult truths," Seawright stated. "The similarity between the Hitler comparisons and certain actions taken by Trump and his followers can be straightforward. ... The challenge arises only when those parallels aren’t accurate.

Certainly, numerous examples exist where prominent Republicans or conservative pundits have employed Nazi references or compared figures to Hitler as a means to criticize Democrats and liberals.

Senator Bernie Moreno of Ohio called Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer from New York "Führer" earlier this month, and Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene from Georgia has tried to connect progressives with a "National Socialist Party."

Lara Logan, a previous broadcast news journalist turned conservative commentator, faced significant criticism throughout the coronavirus pandemic due to comments she made comparing Dr. Anthony Fauci to Josef Mengele, the Nazi doctor known for conducting experiments on Jewish people during the Holocaust.

Meanwhile, Trump, who was on the 2024 campaign trail, addressed the Nazi-related attacks he received following the Madison Square Garden rally with the aim of shifting the story away from Harris and those supporting her.

They actually use this term; it encompasses two terms: 'He's Hitler,' and then they add, 'He's a Nazi,'" Trump said with an eye roll at a gathering in Georgia mere days prior to the election. "‘I'm not a Nazi... I am the complete opposite of a Nazi... She's the real fascist here, okay? She’s a fascist.'

This tactic has been employed by Trump for decades to deflect Democratic criticisms right back at them, and he has effectively utilized this approach, according to Barbie Zelizer, who researches media and politics at the University of Pennsylvania’s Annenberg School for Communication.

He deflects many of the attacks he faces right back at his opponents; he truly embodies the idea of giving it as good as he gets," Zelizer stated. "Given how much his own political views have evolved over time, he grasps the significance of labeling someone a Nazi, for instance, and the effect it can have.

However, some Democrats believe that drawing parallels between Trump and the Nazis could have greater advantages than disadvantages. They argue that during the upcoming election cycles, voters do not expect restrained language from their leaders as the party prepares to challenge the Republicans.

“The proper intervention ensures that every strategy aimed at Trump remains effective,” stated the Democratic consultant. “Indeed, there’s an element of risk involved; however, the crucial point is preventing your tactics from being turned around against you.”

Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This content must not be republished, distributed, broadcasted, or rewritten without permission.

To get the most recent updates on news, weather, sports, and live videos, visit The Hill.