Luigi Mangione Faces Federal Charges as Prosecutors Seek Death Penalty in Landmark Case

The 26-year-old man charged with murdering UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, Luigi Mangione, is scheduled to appear in federal court on Friday to plead not guilty or guilty to accusations of harassment and homicide.

A week following the indictment of Mangione by a federal grand jury on four counts related to the December 4th murder of an insurance executive, his court appearance took place.

The assassination attempt on Thompson, who was en route to a UnitedHealthcare investors' meeting in New York, has sparked widespread backing for Mangione from individuals harboring intense dissatisfaction and rage towards the U.S. healthcare industry’s profit-driven model.

At Mangione’s final court hearing in February, a considerable number of supporters showed up. Many of them displayed their support by wearing green clothing—a nod to Nintendo’s "Luigi" character—and held placards outside that read “Free Luigi” and “Healthcare is a fundamental human right.”

The most serious federal charge against Mangione, murdering someone with a firearm, carries the possibility of either the death penalty or life imprisonment. according To the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York. Recently, the Justice Department submitted a notification stating their intention to pursue capital punishment, following instructions from Attorney General Pam Bondi who had previously instructed them to aim for such sentencing.

He additionally confronts state charges in New York and Pennsylvania concerning the shooting and the subsequent week-long manhunt.

In New York, he has entered a plea of not guilty to both murder and terrorism charges at the state level. Regarding his case in Pennsylvania, he is facing accusations related to firearms and forgery—specifically concerning an alleged 3D-printed weapon and fake identifications found with him during his arrest at a McDonald’s in Altoona. Prior to being sent back to New York for those charges, he had not yet entered a plea in the Pennsylvania matter.

An attorney representing Mangione submitted multiple motions in the Pennsylvania state courts aiming to have the charges dismissed and certain pieces of evidence suppressed, anticipating a potential trial. The legal team argued that Mangione had been unlawfully detained and searched by law enforcement officials. They also asked that his seized documents not be characterized as a manifesto.

How we got here

The accusations arise from the shooting of Thompson on December 4 in Midtown Manhattan, which initiated a five-day search for the suspect.

Mangione was apprehended in relation to the homicide in Pennsylvania, which was over 270 miles distant from where the incident occurred. According to officials, he reportedly had possession of a counterfeit identification card utilized by the alleged perpetrator, as well as what investigators think was the firearm involved in the crime, along with a hand-written "statement of culpability."

Mangione did not have coverage through UnitedHealthcare; however, when he was arrested, investigators reportedly found a hand-written notebook containing "hostility towards the health insurance sector and affluent leaders specifically," as stated in a federal complaint. Additionally, the NYPD mentioned that three 9mm cartridge cases recovered from the location featured the terms "delay," "deny," and "depose" inscribed on them, which seems to reference a 2010 publication that exposed strategies used within the insurance business.

Mangione has received backing from those who view the U.S. healthcare insurance sector as dysfunctional, excessively costly, and prone to rejecting coverage. A report published in June 2023 by the non-profit health policy analysis organization KFF revealed that most insured adult Americans encountered at least one problem with their health insurance over the course of a year, such as claim denials.

By April 24, a legal defense fund had been established. in support of Mangione has raised more than $900,000.

"To be frank, I'm not particularly astonished that we're seeing such extensive backing emerging at this juncture for this young individual accused of taking such actions," stated Sam Beard, a representative for the December 4th Legal Committee—the organization raising funds for Mangione. previously told CNN.

"I believe Americans are tired of how the healthcare insurance system functions," Beard mentioned additionally.

At the same time, prominent political figures have condemned Mangione’s purported acts as appalling offenses and asserted that he ought to encounter severe repercussions.

In America, we do not resort to taking lives indiscriminately to settle policy disputes or convey our opinions," Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro stated on the same day Mangione was arrested. "He certainly does not qualify as a hero.

High public interest in Mangione

The highly divisive opinions surrounding his case have drawn significant public scrutiny towards Mangione.

In December, Mangione was swiftly transported from Pennsylvania to lower Manhattan in New York City via private jet and helicopter, drawing significant attention as media crews captured the event. Upon arrival in New York, Mangione was escorted through a prolonged "perp walk" by an array of heavily armed NYPD officers. Following closely were New York Mayor Eric Adams and NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch.

The defense claims that law enforcement and prosecutors acted improperly by catering to the television cameras during that event.

On February 21, Mangione's court appearance in New York regarding the state charges attracted numerous supporters, who braved the freezing cold and lengthy queues to get into the courthouse.

Several individuals sported "Free Luigi" scarves and pullovers, chanting phrases that backed his cause while condemning the U.S. healthcare sector. Among those present at the event was Chelsea Manning, formerly an army intelligence analyst for the United States who had been sentenced under the Espionage Act following her disclosure of classified information to WikiLeaks.

During that court hearing, Mangione opted for a green sweater—a sartorial decision that prosecutors claimed was deliberately chosen by the defense. "While they have protested loudly whenever external parties beyond their control have made public comments or actions," prosecutors stated in a recent submission, "the defense simultaneously has stoked the fires of public interest."

Moreover, prosecutors disclosed that Mangione’s lawyers gave him a fresh pair of argyle socks containing concealed heart-shaped messages of encouragement. Mangione’s legal team subsequently stated they had "accidentally failed to notice" the notes inside the socks.

In the end, Mangione chose not to wear those socks during the hearing.

READ MORE: Luigi Mangione is heading to court on federal charges, and prosecutors have filed notices indicating their intent to pursue the death penalty.

CHECK OUT WPTZ: Stay updated with the newest news from Plattsburgh and Burlington today. Check out the top headline stories and access the most recent weather updates online at your convenience.